Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Last updated on October 16, 2026
Really Great Cat Litter from Tuft + Paw comes in three formulas: Charcoal, Lavender and OdorStop. Charcoal and Lavender are plant-based tofu litters, while OdorStop blends tofu and pea pellets with bentonite clay for extra odor control.
The names don’t tell you much about how they differ. Here’s what each one does, where it falls short, and which one to buy.
Quick Picks
Unscented Pick: Really Great Cat Litter Charcoal
Lightly Scented Pick: Really Great Cat Litter Lavender
Multi-Cat Pick: Really Great Cat Litter OdorStop
What Really Great Cat Litter Is Made Of
Charcoal and Lavender share a tofu-based formula of soybean fiber, calcium carbonate, corn starch and pea fiber. OdorStop is different. It mixes charcoal tofu pellets, pea pellets with an odor-control additive, and sodium bentonite clay balls.
Tuft + Paw says all three are 99% dust-free and triple-screened, with pellets designed not to stick to paws. The large majority of reviewers report low dust and less tracking than they had before.
One limit applies to every formula: Tuft + Paw says it may not work reliably in many automatic litter boxes. If you use one, our guide to the best cat litter for automatic litter boxes covers better fits.
Really Great Cat Litter Formulas Compared
| Formula | Scent | Odor Control Ingredients (per Tuft + Paw) | Tracking Claim | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Charcoal | Unscented | Activated carbon | Ultra low-tracking | No added fragrance |
| Lavender | Light lavender | Dried lavender petals, 1% | Ultra low-tracking | A light natural scent |
| OdorStop | Not specified | Charcoal tofu pellets, pea pellets, bentonite clay | Low-tracking | Multi-cat homes |
Really Great Cat Litter Charcoal
Why It Stands Out
It’s unscented and uses activated carbon for odor. Reviewers report efficient clumping, and one preferred it over the pine pellets they used before.
Possible Downsides
With no scent, odor control depends on scooping and the carbon. Some reviewers felt it didn’t hold poop odor as well as urine odor.
Best For
Homes that want a low-dust tofu litter with no added scent.
Really Great Cat Litter Lavender
Why It Stands Out
Tuft + Paw scents it with real dried lavender petals at a 1% concentration, not essential oils. It shares the same base and pellet as Charcoal.
Possible Downsides
It’s still a scented litter, so it won’t suit a home that’s avoiding added fragrance.
Best For
Owners who want a light natural scent rather than perfume.
Really Great Cat Litter OdorStop
Why It Stands Out
It’s the only formula with clay mixed in. Tuft + Paw adds the bentonite and pea pellets for multi-cat strength odor control, and one reviewer with several cats reports good odor control.
Possible Downsides
The clay means it isn’t fully plant-based, so it won’t suit owners who chose tofu to avoid clay. Tuft + Paw labels it low-tracking, though some of its product text calls it ultra low-tracking.
Best For
Homes with more than one cat.
Tips for Using Really Great Cat Litter
- Some reviewers say fresh clumps stay soft for a short while, so waiting a few minutes before scooping helps them come out whole.
- A scoop with wide slots lets the pellets fall through. Our cat litter scoop guide covers the options.
- Pellets feel different from fine clay. If your cat hesitates, try a second box with the new litter beside the old one.
Which Really Great Cat Litter Should You Choose?
Start with Charcoal if you want an unscented tofu litter with activated carbon for odor control. Pick Lavender if you’d like a light scent. Go with OdorStop for a multi-cat home if you don’t mind some clay in the mix.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Lavender formula smell strong?
Tuft + Paw describes the lavender scent as light and gentle, but how noticeable it feels depends on your preference. If you want to avoid added scent altogether, Charcoal is the better choice.
How do I switch my cat to Really Great Cat Litter?
Tuft + Paw doesn’t give switching directions. Set up a second box with the new litter beside the old one so your cat can choose. Our guide on how to transition cat litter covers it.
Is Really Great Cat Litter good for kittens?
AAHA recommends starting kittens with unscented clumping sand litter, the litter they previously used, or both. Charcoal is the unscented option here, but its tofu pellets have a different texture. Let your kitten’s preferences guide the choice.
